Ernie is a talented piano player who has his own bar in New York City. Holden has been to this bar with D.B. in the past, so he decides to visit once more when he reaches the city after leaving Pencey. When he arrives, though, he hates how many “phonies” are there, including D.B.’s ex-girlfriend Lillian, and also dislikes the showboating way that Ernie plays the piano.