The Secret History: Chapter 2  Summary & Analysis

Richard gets ready for his lunch with Bunny but is concerned that his best clothes will make him too hot in the warm weather. When he enters the shared bathroom, he spots Judy Poovey, a fellow Californian. Judy tells Richard a story about a time when she was at a party and Camilla bumped into her. This incident led to a drunken fight in which Henry broke the collarbone and ribs of a tough kid name Spike Romney. Because of the fight, Judy doesn’t like Henry or Camilla. However, she is fond of Bunny and thinks he’s funny. After she finishes her story, Judy offers Richard a different jacket, which she stole from the Costume shop. Judy is a costume design major, so to her the jacket is no big deal, but Richard finds it surprisingly nice. 

When Bunny sees Richard, he immediately complements his jacket but tells him it’s not appropriate for the time of year. Nonetheless, they make their way to the restaurant where Bunny has put in a reservation. Bunny knows the restaurant well and even claims to be friends with the Maître d’, though he’s not in today. On the way to their table, Bunny makes Richard uncomfortable by loudly whispering, “Queers love to work in restaurants.” The waiter, who hears Bunny, angrily shows Richard and Bunny to their seats, though Bunny doesn’t seem to realize—or care—that he has caused offense.

Bunny asks Richard how often he goes to The Polo, the nicest restaurant in town. Richard responds, “Not much,” despite the fact that he’s never heard of it. Bunny tells Richard that his father took him to The Polo for his first drink. Bunny also tells him a story about going to a place called the Oak Bar where he ran up the tab and then left without paying. Later, Bunny returned to the Oak Bar with his father and his old bill got added on to the new one. However, his father didn’t notice. After telling this story, Bunny sees the waiter on his way to their table and says, “Look, here comes Twinkletoes.”

Bunny orders a gaudy drink and tells Richard that he first drank one while in Jamaica. Richard changes the subject and asks Bunny his thoughts on Henry. Bunny likes Henry, but says that he is hard to live with, primarily because he doesn’t like having fun. Instead, Henry spends his time studying; he knows at least seven languages and can read hieroglyphics. Bunny shocks Richard by telling him that Henry is from Missouri and that his father is probably some sort of construction tycoon. Bunny’s never met Henry’s father—Henry is quite secret about his home life—but he did see Henry’s mother once. She was attractive and clearly rich, though Bunny says the family is “new money.”

Bunny shifts the conversation back to Richard by asking him what his father does. Richard responds with, “Oil,” which is technically true, but deliberately misleading. Wanting to change the subject, Richard asks how Henry came by his intelligence. Bunny tells Richard that Henry was in a bad accident when he was young that took him out of school for years. In that time, Henry read voraciously and never stopped. After this conversation, their waiter returns. When he leaves, Bunny once again uses a homophobic slur and says that gay people should be rounded up and burned at the stake. At this point, Richard realizes the extent of Bunny’s homophobia. He asks what Bunny thinks about Francis, suggesting he might be gay. Bunny dismisses the notion and moves the conversation back to Richard by asking if he has a girlfriend. This time, Richard tells the full truth and says no.

Bunny tells Richard that he has a girlfriend who is an elementary-education major and is “a real girl.” He says that he prefers his girlfriend to someone like Camilla, who “lacks a mother’s firm hand.” Abruptly, Bunny stops talking, as though he is disturbed by something. However, he returns to normal when he sees their food is coming.

Bunny and Richard spend their entire afternoon in the restaurant, eating expensive food and drinking expensive drinks. By the end of the day, both of them are quite drunk. Realizing they have overstayed their welcome, Richard suggests they leave. Bunny agrees and then asks Richard to pay the check, claiming he left his wallet at home. Richard is alarmed because Bunny had previously agreed to pay for everything, and he is in no position to be able to do so himself. Richard tells Bunny he cannot pay so Bunny leaves and calls Henry. He tells Richard it is no big deal, and that Henry will be there soon. Indeed, Henry shows up and pays the check.

Henry gives Richard and Bunny a ride home from the restaurant. During the ride, Bunny repeatedly tries to make casual conversation, but Henry refuses to humor him. Richard worries that Henry is mad at him. After Henry drops Bunny off, he apologizes to Richard on Bunny’s behalf. Apparently, Bunny often pulls a similar stunt where he asks someone out to a nice meal and then pretends to forget his wallet. At first, Richard refuses to believe it was anything but an honest mistake, but then Henry reminds him that Bunny paid for their cab earlier in the day.

The next day, Charles and Camilla invite Richard to take a walk with them. He agrees and they start to walk and talk about his lunch with Bunny. They tell him the incident was no big deal and that Henry isn’t angry with him. Richard questions Bunny and Henry’s friendship, but Charles and Camilla assure him that the two are best friends, despite their contrasting demeanors. During the walk, Camilla points out an old cemetery, which is all that remains of a town from the 1700s. She tells Richard that it is beautiful, and he should visit it sometime, particularly in the snow. They also come across three ravens. Richard is shocked—he’s never seen such birds before—and Charles jokingly suggests that it might be an omen.

Near the end of their walk, Charles and Camilla invite Richard over for dinner. At first, he declines, but he ultimately accepts after they assure him that it would be no trouble for him to join. After arriving at their house, Charles and Camilla ask Richard about the other Californians at Hampden. Richard tells them that he doesn’t know many except Judy. Unsurprisingly, the dislike between Camilla and Judy is mutual, and Camilla seems annoyed when Richard jokingly brings it up.

Charles and Camilla tell Richard that Hampden is the “last place on earth for the worst people in the world.” They are half-joking, but also believe there is some truth to that idea. They use Henry as an example. Apparently, Henry is a 10th-grade dropout who refused to take the SATs. No good college would’ve let Henry in if not for Hampden. During this conversation, Richard begins to feel ill. He’s still hung over from his lunch with Bunny, and the whiskey he’s just consumed starts to make him nauseous.

Before the conversation can continue, Bunny and Henry arrive. Richard excuses himself to the kitchen, where he gets himself a glass of water. Charles follows close behind to check on the lamb chops he’s cooking. The smell of lamb only nauseates Richard further, and he feels a strong desire to get out of the house. Before long, Bunny and Henry also end up in the kitchen, Henry in search of some aspirin and Bunny in search of food.

When Henry notices that Richard doesn’t look well, Richard tells him it’s “just a headache.” Meanwhile, Charles chastises Bunny for eating the lamb before he can serve it. Richard is quiet throughout dinner while his new friends engage in pedantic conversations. Richard leaves early and walks home, “straining to remember exact words, telling inflections, any subtle insults or kindnesses [he] might’ve missed.” When he returns home, he lays down and watches as the wind ruffles through the pages of the Parmenides, a book he's been reading.

Richard wakes up late the following morning and has to rush to Julian’s office to make it in time for class. Bunny lightly ribs Richard for his tardiness, but before he can get far, Julian arrives. Class begins and it’s a particularly rough day for Richard because he's behind. Richard enjoys the days where class is spent talking about philosophy but finds the classes that focus on grammar and prose composition “brutal, bludgeoning labor.” Unfortunately, the latter category is what the majority of the class consists of. As Richard works throughout the week, he thinks that he’s alienated himself from the other Greek students and feels that they are cold to him.

Richard starts to think that he’s made a mistake by joining Julian’s classes. He wonders whether his decision was made too hastily. Hoping a meeting with Julian will make him feel better, Richard heads to Julian’s office. However, he stops just short of it because he hears the voices of Julian and Henry. Richard hears Henry say, “Should I do what is necessary?” In response, Julian takes Henry’s hands and says, “You should only, ever, do what is necessary.” Confused, Richard watches as Henry gives Julian a “quick little businesslike kiss on the cheek” and then walks away. Not wanting to be seen, Richard sneaks down the stairs and then runs away.

The following week is isolating and bizarre for Richard. The weather gradually gets colder, and he feels completely detached from those around him. He spends his evenings working on Greek and reading his favorite book, The Great Gatsby. Unfortunately, all Richard can think about when he reads the novel are the similarities between himself and Gatsby. That weekend, Richard attends a party. He knows the other Greek students don’t like parties and will not be in attendance.

At the party, Richard talks to a girl he finds attractive but annoying. When she realizes Richard is a Greek student, she warns him to be careful because the other Greek students “worship the fucking Devil.” Richard doesn’t take her warning seriously, but she insists that she’s heard a lot of concerning rumors about the Greek students from another student named Seth Gartrell. Gartrell is an artist Richard thinks is a pretentious fake. As such, he does not care for Seth and says so. The girl he's talking to takes offense because Seth is her friend, and she thinks he’s a “genius.” Richard starts to argue with the girl but doesn’t get far before Camilla shows up and pulls him away. She tells Richard that she and Francis are going to Francis’s place in the countryside and extends him an invitation. Richard accepts and they leave immediately.

Francis, Camilla, and Richard ride in a Mustang convertible until they reach the country house. The house is immense—it is more like a castle than a house—and Richard is in awe when he sees it. Francis tells him that it belongs to his aunt, and it is empty most of the year. Francis and Camilla begin to give Richard a tour, as the sound of a piano filters in from a back room. When they enter the library, Richard spots Charles at the piano. As it turns out, all the Greek students have come to stay for the weekend.

Richard admits that his memories of the past are “distant and blurry” before his arrival at the country house. However, from this point forward, he feels that his memories, “for the first time” will appear “in shapes very like their bright old selves.” He thinks of this moment as the turning point in his relationship with the other Greek students. The house is beloved by both Richard and the Greek students; each room holds a new surprise, and it is revealed to Richard piece by piece.

On Saturday, Henry and Camilla take Richard out in a rowboat on the nearby lake. As Henry rows, he talks about a passage from T. S. Eliot’s The Wasteland. Although Richard now knows the corresponding lines from the poem and recites them, at the time he had no idea what Henry was talking about. When Richard, Henry, and Camilla return from their boat ride, they find the others playing Go Fish because it’s the only card game that Bunny knows how to play.

The next morning, Richard wakes up early and goes outside where he finds Henry. Henry is working on a Latin translation of Milton’s Paradise Lost; a project he’s doing for fun, rather than for school. After a brief conversation about Milton, Henry abruptly says to Richard, “You’re not very happy where you come from, are you?” Richard is taken aback, though Henry promises not to tell the others the truth about his background. This moment gives Richard a newfound respect for Henry, and he begins to realize why the other Greek students like him so much.

Richard believes that his Fall semester at Hampden made him who he is as a person. Though the Greek students are strange, they help to develop his personality. Each of the other students has their own quirks. Henry, though highly intelligent, is completely unaware of contemporary events. Richard recounts an anecdote where Henry is shocked to learn that men have walked on the moon. Meanwhile, Bunny has a girlfriend named Marion, whom he never brings around the Greek students because they don’t get along. Richard still remembers the times Bunny would come to his room to hide from Marion, only for Marion to come and find him anyway. Though Richard likes all of the Greek students, he prefers the twins and spends much of his time with them.

Richard’s favorite memories of his first semester are of the time he spends in the countryside. While there, the Greek students drink, read, and relax. Among other activities, they shoot guns, play croquet, and cook elaborate dinners. On occasion, Julian comes for dinner, and everyone is on their best behavior. Richard remembers finding the dinners “troublesome” at the time but looks back on them fondly. At each dinner, Julian gives the same toast: “Live forever.”

Richard finds himself wondering how he spent so much time with the Greek students, “yet knew so little of what was happening at the end of that term.” He says that there are “plenty of things they didn’t let me in on and would not for some time.” In retrospect, he realizes that there were many clues he should have picked up on. In particular, he cites the others getting angry when Bunny randomly bursts into a rendition of “The Farmer in the Dell.” Also, they would often show up with injuries and had “a strange preoccupation with the weather.” In addition, Richard overhears a strange conversation between the twins about bed sheets and, in a separate incident, finds a boiling pot of revolting “blackish water” on the stove, which Francis claims is for his bath.

One day, late into the Fall semester, Richard goes outside and finds Francis and Bunny drinking prairie oysters to cure their hangovers. After a brief conversation about the best cure for a hangover, Francis suggests they walk to the lake, and everyone comes except Bunny. At the lake, Richard and Camilla wade in the water together and Richard thinks about how beautiful she is. Suddenly, Camilla steps on something sharp and blood begins to appear in the water around them. She lifts her foot to find that a shard of green glass has cut an artery.

While everyone else appears stunned, Henry comes to Camilla’s rescue and takes charge. He orders Francis to get the first aid kit and tells Richard to make a tourniquet while he holds Camilla in his arms. Though Richard is shocked, he is also struck by the beauty of the moment and thinks that it would make for a great painting. Charles runs down to help Camilla and eventually removes the shard of glass from her foot. Afterwards, Francis and Bunny take Camilla to the emergency room; Francis goes out of obligation and concern, while Bunny goes because he’s mad that he’s missed all of the excitement.

Later in the day, Charles and Richard talk about their desire to stay in the countryside home forever. Charles tells Richard that it might be possible; Francis will likely inherit the home and if he doesn’t, then Henry could buy it. Charles says that such a set-up would be perfect for Henry, who wants to spend his life writing books rather than teaching. Richard loves the idea but knows it sounds too good to be true. Meanwhile, Bunny and Henry are out in the yard playing croquet and laughing. While remembering this moment, Richard says, “That laughter haunts me still.”