The Sirens of Titan

by

Kurt Vonnegut

The Sirens of Titan: Chapter 12: The Gentleman From Tralfamadore Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Titan is the only moon in the Solar System with an oxygen atmosphere. It also has a pleasant temperature and three seas and three seas, which are each named after Rumfoord. Although it is unclear why, the spirals of Rumfoord, Kazak, and Titan precisely coincide, such that while Rumfoord and Kazak only materialize on other planets temporarily, they are permanently materialized on Titan. They live on an island there, in a “flawless reproduction” of the Taj Mahal, which Rumfoord has humorously named Dun Roamin.
This passage confirms that Rumfoord exists in multiple places at one time. While he only exists on Earth once every 59 days, and on Mars every 111 days, he is always on Titan, due a sort of physical fluke. He has thus, somewhat strangely, ended up making a home there.
Themes
Wealth, Power, and Inequality Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
The only other person on Titan is Salo. He is 11 million Earthling years old. His skin is the color of a tangerine; he has three legs, and each of his feet is an inflatable sphere that becomes a suction cup when deflated. He has no arms and three eyes, with a round head that hangs “on gimbals.” His voice is something like a bike horn, and he speaks 5,000 languages. In 483,441 B.C.E. Salo was telepathically determined to be the most handsome, healthy, and morally upstanding being on his planet. The government on Tralfamadore, a kind of “hypnotic anarchy,” was celebrating its 100 millionth anniversary.
One of the surprising twists of the novel is that Salo ends up emerging as the most sympathetic character of all. The reason why is surprising is because—as indicated here—he is so strange and different to humans that it is almost impossible to imagine him existing.
Themes
Religion and the Search for Meaning Theme Icon
Wealth, Power, and Inequality Theme Icon
Thousands of years ago, Salo is nominated to carry a message from Tralfamadore across the universe. It has been prepared by a sort of Tralfamadorian equivalent of a university, and is sealed in a lead wafer, submerged in water, and clamped around Salo’s neck. He is strictly instructed not to open the message until he reaches his destination. Titan, where he is stuck, is still 18 million light years away from the place he’s going. Once he gets there, he is supposed to learn the language of its beings and then translate the message for them. As a Tralfamadorian, Salo is a machine, and thus follows these orders without question. Indeed, he has internalized the instruction not to open the message as “the very core of [his] being.”
It is significant that Vonnegut uses the word “machine” to describe Salo, rather than “robot.” Robot arguably conjures a more specific and less lifelike image of a cold, artificial form of intelligence. The word “machine,” however, lends itself to a wider variety of meanings. Human and animal bodies are, after all, often symbolically likened to machines. While there is definitely something inorganic and artificial about Salo, he is perhaps closer to humans than what most people imagine when confronted with the word “robot.”
Themes
Free Will vs. External Control Theme Icon
Religion and the Search for Meaning Theme Icon
Wealth, Power, and Inequality Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Quotes
Salo is stranded on Titan due to technical problems on his spaceship resulting from a missing part that is no larger than a can opener. Without it, the spaceship can only travel comparatively short distances across the Solar System. Once stranded, Salo sends a message about his problems back to Tralfamadore, which takes 150,000 years to arrive. While waiting, Salo makes sculptures, grows daisies, and watches the activities of Earthlings. One day, while watching, he finds a message on Earth’s surface written in Tralfamadorian, in what the Earthlings called Stonehenge. The message reads, “Replacement part being rushed with all possible speed.”
The activities Salo pursues while waiting to be rescued also do not seem like the kind of things that a machine would do. Indeed, part of what makes Salo so sympathetic is that he pursues activities that not only seem human, but especially creative and tender.
Themes
Free Will vs. External Control Theme Icon
Religion and the Search for Meaning Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Get the entire The Sirens of Titan LitChart as a printable PDF.
The Sirens of Titan PDF
After that, Salo receives four further messages; the first is the Great Wall of China, the second is Emperor Nero’s Golden House, the third is the Kremlin, and the fourth is the Palace of the League of Nations. Each assures Salo that he is abandoned, and one tells him to prepare to be able to leave at a moment’s notice. Yet Salo also knows that not every message is carried out; often whole civilizations implode before they can build the structure that contained a message for him. Salo hasn’t told Rumfoord all of this, for fear that Rumfoord will be horrified that all of human history exists only to deliver Salo his missing part. Salo loves Rumfoord, not in a sexual manner—as he is a machine—but in a different way.
The fact that each of these famous landmarks—as well as human civilization itself—purportedly only exist in order to send messages to Salo is one of the most spectacular satirical twists in the novel. It forces the reader to ask themselves what they would think if they learned that the entirety of human history only existed as a tool for another species to complete a single task.
Themes
Free Will vs. External Control Theme Icon
Religion and the Search for Meaning Theme Icon
Wealth, Power, and Inequality Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
According to Tralfamadorian myth, the beings that preexisted the machines that now live there were organic, and obsessed with the idea that “everything had a purpose.” Not only this, but they ranked different purposes, and felt humiliated and horrified when they had to perform a role for a purpose that wasn’t high enough. When this happened, they invented machines to do this role for them. Eventually, the beings assigned the machines they’d built to learn the purpose of the beings’ existence. The machines concluded that the beings didn’t have one, and in horror, the beings slaughtered each other. Before long, they gave this job to the machines, too, and almost instantaneously all the beings were dead.
This passage is particularly fascinating to read from a contemporary perspective. Although computers and other forms of advanced machine existed in 1959, these technologies were nothing like what exists in the present day. Yet here Vonnegut indirectly expresses many of the same fears that people are voicing about artificial intelligence and automation today. Will machines enhance human life, make it seem meaningless, or even cause its extinction?
Themes
Free Will vs. External Control Theme Icon
Religion and the Search for Meaning Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Quotes
Salo watches as the spaceship containing Constant, Beatrice, and Chrono descends onto Titan. He has made a sculpture garden of two million life-size sculptures of humans. Salo is fascinated by the boundless human appetite for entertainment. Along with the sculptures, he has become skilled at daisy-breeding, and now grows daisies so large they weigh more than one ton. Salo inflates his feet as he goes to greet the newcomers. He calls Rumfoord “Skip” (which Rumfoord dislikes) in order to establish a sense of intimacy between them. Searching for Rumfoord, Salo looks into Rumfoord’s pool. At the bottom are statues of the three sirens of Titan made by Salo.
While it is Salo who is technically the unfeeling “machine,” he is much kinder to Rumfoord than Rumfoord is to him. Salo treasures his relationship with Rumfoord. This indicates that it is actually Rumfoord who is cold, cruel, and machine-like, in the sense that he only cares about himself and isn’t capable of making genuine connections with others.
Themes
Religion and the Search for Meaning Theme Icon
Wealth, Power, and Inequality Theme Icon
Kazak runs toward Salo, but immediately Salo notices that something is wrong; Kazak looks poisoned. Suddenly, Kazak lights up with Saint Elmo’s fire, an electrical discharge that makes a creature look like they are on fire, when they actually aren’t. Salo then spots Rumfoord, who has a “band of dematerialization” running through him, meaning a strip of him is completely missing. Weakly, Rumfoord explains, “Sunspots.” A storm on the sun has affected the chrono-synclastic infundibulum. Sunspots have made Rumfoord and Kazak ill before, but not like this. Rumfoord snaps irritably at Salo, and Salo is horrified.
The fact that Rumfoord’s illness is caused by sunspots links his fate to the myth of Icarus. According to this myth, a man named Icarus was able to fly after making himself wings from feather and wax (which is comparable to Rumfoord’s ability to travel through time, thanks to the chrono-synclastic infundibulum). However, when Icarus flies to close to the sun—an act of hubris—his wings melt and he dies. This parallel perhaps suggests that a similar fate will befall Rumfoord. 
Themes
Wealth, Power, and Inequality Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Irritated, Rumfoord suggests that he and Salo “drop this guise of friendship.” Salo is heartbroken, and tells Rumfoord he thought they really were friends; however, Rumfoord replies that they are just using each other for their respective purposes. Salo lists all the kind things he has done for Rumfoord. He is grieving through his noisy suction-cup feet, which further irritates Rumfoord. Miserable, Salo says that if he could cry like an Earthling, he would do that instead. Rumfoord mentions that the replacement part Salo has been waiting for will arrive imminently. He then projectile vomits.
The horrifying cruelty with which Rumfoord treats the kind-hearted, innocent Salo is almost too much to bear. It confirms Rumfoord as the villain of the story and Salo as its surprising hero. Despite the fact that Salo only appears at the end of the novel, he is purer and nobler than all the other characters, and is thus quickly established as the book’s most sympathetic character.
Themes
Wealth, Power, and Inequality Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Salo realizes that Rumfoord now knows that he was personally being controlled by Tralfamadore, and that this has likely upset him severely. Now, Rumfoord shouts that the Tralfamadorians have used him like a “potato peeler.” This was one of the aspects of the future that Rumfoord denied even to himself, refusing to believe it was true. Rumfoord rudely belittles Salo for being a machine. Despite being deeply hurt, Salo resorts to groveling. However, at this moment Rumfoord informs him that very soon, an explosion on the sun will blow his spaceship out of the chrono-synclastic infundibulum and all the way out of the Solar System. Salo is horrified, but Rumfoord insists that he doesn’t pity him.
On some level, it is perhaps understandable that Rumfoord is so furious about being used. It arguably makes sense that he reacts with such devastation to the realization that his entire civilization is akin to a “potato peeler” for the Tralfamadorians. However, Rumfoord seems less concerned about the way the Tralfamadorians treated humanity than he is about he was treated personally—it seems he egotistically wanted to be the exception to the rule.
Themes
Free Will vs. External Control Theme Icon
Wealth, Power, and Inequality Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Rumfoord tries to hide the fact that he is crying. As a parting wish, he demands to know the contents of Salo’s message. Salo hesitates, but Rumfoord insists “in the name of our friendship.” Meanwhile, Constant, Beatrice, and Chrono have finally arrived on Titan. They are each leaning against one of Salo’s statues. The statue Beatrice is leaning against, entitled “Discovery of Atomic Power,” depicts a young, seemingly noble student of physics. Beatrice hasn’t noticed that the statue has a large erection. Meanwhile, Chrono is leaning against a statue depicting a Neanderthal family committing cannibalism.
Salo’s attempt to memorialize important moments in human history has produced some rather comic results. Yet in a sense, it is only arbitrary human norms that define an erection or cannibalism as inappropriate topics to be celebrated. After all, they are as much a part of human history as the discovery of atomic energy—and who is to say that they are less noteworthy?
Themes
Free Will vs. External Control Theme Icon
Religion and the Search for Meaning Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Constant announces that he will never allow himself to be used for someone else’s purposes again. It is the same speech he has made again and again over the 17 months it took his family to travel from Earth to Titan. Beatrice is not angry with Constant, only disinterested. She and Chrono maintain their deep bond, but neither of them feel any affection for Constant. Chrono spots a creature rowing a “gilded rowboat” in the distance, near Rumfoord’s palace. The creature is Salo, who is rowing for the first time and isn’t very good at it. When Salo pulls up, Chrono threatens him with his knife, while Beatrice picks up a rock with which to smash his head.
The sweetness and innocence of Salo compared to the human characters again paints humanity in a rather poor light. It is obvious that while Salo comes from a highly intelligent, wise, and good-natured species, humans tend toward ignorance, megalomania, and aggression. This further complicates the moral dilemma surrounding the Tralfamadorians’ use of humans for their own ends.
Themes
Free Will vs. External Control Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Salo tells them they are welcome to kill him. He says he wishes he was dead. He tells them that Rumfoord is dying and that he wants to see them, but never wants to see Salo again. When the family find him, Rumfoord makes an effort to speak to them warmly. He greets Beatrice as “wife,” Constant as “Space Wanderer,” and Chrono as “German batball star.” Rumfoord tells them that he is not dying, because, from his “chrono-synclastic infundibulated” perspective, everything always remains and everything that has ever happened is still happening. He then tells them that everything that has happened on Earth has been “warped” and controlled by the Tralfamadorians.
The kindness that Rumfoord shows the other human characters toward the end of the novel arguably indicates that he is not entirely evil. At the same time, his cruel treatment of Salo, which has made Salo so miserable that he is suicidal (quite a feat for a machine) is difficult to forgive. It is clear that Rumfoord feels a species-based sense of loyalty to the other humans, yet the novel suggests that this may be harmful in its own way.
Themes
Free Will vs. External Control Theme Icon
Religion and the Search for Meaning Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Rumfoord then points at Chrono and explains that Chrono has the part that Salo needs. It is the good-luck piece. He explains that he asked Salo to show him the secret message he is carrying across the universe, but because Salo is a machine, he can’t disobey his orders. An electrical spiral envelops Rumfoord; he acknowledges that this is the end, and in parting says he has done his best to serve Earth and hopes that now that Salo’s message can resume, the Tralfamadorians will leave Earthlings alone. He asks to be remembered as “a gentleman of Newport, Earth, and the Solar System,” then says goodbye and disappears with Kazak forever.
Rumfoord’s myopic loyalty to his own kind ends up being perhaps his greatest sin—whether to himself or to Earth, he is unable to extend empathy to others on the basis that they are different for him. Of course, Rumfoord is also arguably lying when he claims he did his best to serve Earth, considering he created a whole Martian Army to attack Earth in an enormous war.
Themes
Free Will vs. External Control Theme Icon
Wealth, Power, and Inequality Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Just at this moment, Salo comes racing over, shouting “Skip! The message! I’ll tell you the message!” However, he then realizes with a start that Rumfoord is dead. He then immediately begins to chastise himself for being such a terrible machine, full of weaknesses and flaws. Salo lays the message on Rumfoord’s empty chair, explaining that he is no longer really a machine anymore because he managed to disobey his most important command. The message is a single dot, and Salo explains—to the air where Rumfoord used to be—that the dot means “Greetings” in Tralfamadorian.
Here Salo faces a terrible dilemma, feeling that he has failed as both an organic being and as a machine. The fact that the message he is carrying is so simple highlights the absurdity of the whole mission, and thus also of human existence. Again, the reader is forced to question how he or she would feel if he or she learned that humanity only existed to serve such a mundane and seemingly insignificant goal.
Themes
Free Will vs. External Control Theme Icon
Religion and the Search for Meaning Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Quotes
Having announced this, Salo races away and kills himself by disassembling his parts and flinging them all over. Chrono walks among the scattered parts and thinks about how he always knew that his good-luck piece belonged to some other, superior being, because this is how good-luck pieces work. He feels happy to play a small role in the broader story, and drops his good-luck piece among Salo’s scattered parts, certain that everything will ultimately work out.
In the end, Chrono and Salo both provide glimpses of hope. Whereas Salo shows that—even as a machine—it is possible to betray one’s orders in the name of love, Chrono shows that humans don’t have to be so egotistical and hubristic to want to be at the center of the universe.
Themes
Free Will vs. External Control Theme Icon
Religion and the Search for Meaning Theme Icon
Wealth, Power, and Inequality Theme Icon
Human Intelligence, Foolishness, and Hubris Theme Icon
Quotes