Fish in a Tree: Chapter 19 Summary & Analysis

Mom smiles when Ally, Albert, and Keisha walk into Petersen's. She seats them in a booth and takes their ice cream order. Albert wants to know if it's free and then suggests that Mr. Daniels isn't a trusting person. He says that Mr. Daniels wanted to know about his bruises and seemed to think they came from Albert's parents, which isn't true. Keisha says that she's also curious where the bruises come from. Quietly, Albert says that a group of bullies beats him up most days after school. When Keisha asks why Albert doesn't hit the bullies back, Albert says he doesn't believe in violence and is afraid he'll be blamed for hitting first.

Albert stares at his ice cream and then says it reminds him of Ellis Island. At Keisha's prodding, he says that immigrants on Ellis Island sometimes got ice cream. They didn't know what it was, so they spread it on toast like butter. Albert says he feels as though the same thing is happening to him: the bullies think he's a fighter, so they fight him. Exasperatedly, Keisha says that the bullies fight Albert because he won't fight back. Ally suggests that Albert ask for help from his parents, but Albert says he wants to solve this himself. Keisha points out angrily that he can solve this by fighting back, since he's bigger. Albert says the bullies are like fire ants in that they're small and overwhelming. Ally laughs, though she feels sad.

Keisha continues to angrily try to convince Albert to fight back, while he continues to cite his pacifist beliefs and looks progressively more upset. When Keisha asks Albert what it would take to get him to fight back, Ally tries to engage Albert in a conversation about why he likes science. Albert asks Ally why Shay is so mean to her in particular. Keisha also wants to know.

Hesitantly, Ally says that she won the art award last year, which made Shay angry. And on Ally's second day at school, Ally had to sit next to Shay at lunch. She'd brought a bag of cheese crackers with her and midway through lunch, Shay grabbed the bag and ate the crackers. Ally says she used to have more problems with impulse control, which is why, when Shay pulled a piece of cake out of her lunchbox, Ally reached over and grabbed a hunk of cake in retaliation. Keisha laughs while Albert looks wide-eyed. Ally thinks she hates this story—she knew immediately she'd pay for her behavior. She tells the final part: after lunch, she found her own crackers in her pocket, and realized that Shay thought Ally had grabbed her cake for no reason. Keisha keeps laughing and says it's the best story she's ever heard.