Nick’s lawyer. Tanner Bolt is a cheesy but well-known criminal lawyer who has made a career of getting guilty men—often men who have killed their wives—acquitted of their crimes. Tanner has a healthy sense of humor about how strange and psychotic Nick’s case is, and yet wields his expertise almost like a weapon as he helps his new client wade through the endless gauntlet of media appearances, public opinion, police investigations, and—in the midst of it all—finding evidence to support Nick’s argument that Amy has “kidnapped” herself and is framing Nick for her murder as vengeance for his affair with Andie.