Military discipline requires the recruits to follow doctrine immediately and fully, even when it is uncomfortable, dangerous, or difficult. The stories of men dying in freezes, which are likely tall tales, reinforce the importance of total obedience. Frankel’s attempt to quickly punish and dismiss Hendrick hints that he should be in a lot more trouble, but Hendrick is unable to see or understand how hard the Captain is working to protect him, despite his disobedience. In asking to tell his side, he demands an acknowledgement of his individual rights.