Previous
Chapter 23
Themes
Key
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in The Pickwick Papers, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Male Friendship
Predatory Social Institutions
Social Class and Inequality
Marriage and Courtship
Generosity and Forgiveness
Summary
Analysis
The same morning, Pickwick finds Magnus nervously pacing, fully dressed in his finest attire. Magnus, anxious about his upcoming proposal, has already sent his card to Miss Witherfield (the woman he plans to propose to) and expects to meet her at 11. Pickwick tries to calm him, offering advice on how to structure his proposal, emphasizing the need to compliment her beauty, acknowledge his own unworthiness, and then declare his devotion. As the time grows nearer Magnus becomes increasingly nervous but remains determined. When the clock strikes the appointed time, Magnus rushes out to meet Miss Witherfield.
Magnus’s anxiety reflects the weight of societal expectations in marriage, where proposals were rituals involving not only personal affection but also public approval. Pickwick’s advice speaks to the performative nature of courtship, as he encourages Magnus to align his proposal with prescribed social norms.
Themes
After some time, the other Pickwickians arrive, just as Magnus bursts back into the room, elated. He excitedly announces that the proposal has been successful, and he insists that Pickwick meet his fiancée. Magnus leads Pickwick to Miss Witherfield’s room, where Pickwick immediately recognizes her as the woman whose room he mistakenly entered the previous night. The sudden recognition causes both Pickwick and Miss Witherfield to react with shock.
Here, the novel once again turns into a comedy of errors, as Pickwick’s mistake from the night before comes back to bite him. Even though nothing significant happened between Pickwick and Miss Witherfield, the shocked reaction they give each other suggests that neither will be able to easily move on from what happened.
Themes
Magnus, confused and angry, demands an explanation, suspecting some hidden connection between the two. Pickwick refuses to reveal the truth, insisting he will not say anything that might embarrass the lady. Miss Witherfield confirms that she has seen Pickwick before but won’t reveal where or why. Magnus misinterprets the situation and grows increasingly jealous, accusing Pickwick of being deceitful. Tensions rise, and Magnus storms out, declaring that Pickwick will hear from him later.
Pickwick remains silent in order to be honorable and protect Miss Witherfield’s dignity despite the risk to his own reputation. However, as is the case with some of the other instances where Pickwick chooses what he believes to be the honorable route, his silence instead lands him in more trouble. Now, Magnus’s ego is hurt and tensions begin to rise.
Themes
Miss Witherfield, terrified of the possible consequences of Magnus’s jealousy, decides to visit the local magistrate, George Nupkins, to ensure the safety of Magnus. She fears a duel might take place and hopes the magistrate can intervene. At the magistrate’s house, Miss Witherfield reports the incident. Nupkins, eager to maintain law and order, immediately orders his clerk, Mr. Jinks, to issue warrants for the arrest of Pickwick and Tupman.
Miss Witherfield’s fear of a duel is both over-the-top and very real—this was a time when personal disputes could still turn dangerous if they weren’t handled properly. Her decision to involve the magistrate shows that people were starting to turn to legal institutions to manage these kinds of conflicts, instead of resorting to violence to uphold honor. But Nupkins’s reaction also shows how legal systems could overreact, turning misunderstandings into full-blown legal crises.
Themes
Get the entire The Pickwick Papers LitChart as a printable PDF.
Meanwhile, completely unaware of the brewing storm, Pickwick and his friends enjoy a relaxed dinner at their inn. As Pickwick shares the amusing story of his previous night’s mishap, Grummer, the magistrate’s officer, arrives with a group of constables. Grummer proceeds to arrest both Pickwick and Tupman under suspicion of planning a duel. The constables escort the two to the magistrate’s office, much to the amusement of the town’s spectators.
The contrast between the relaxed dinner and the sudden arrest drives home how quickly the Pickwickians latest adventure spirals out of control. Pickwick’s arrest feels ridiculous because it is. Dickens is making a point about how the law often steps in at the worst possible moment, adding chaos instead of resolving it.
Themes
On the way, Sam spots the procession and tries to intervene, demanding to know why his master is being treated like a common criminal. Grummer’s condescending response provokes Sam, who knocks him down. A brawl ensues between Sam, Winkle, and the constables. Despite their best efforts, the group is overpowered and taken into custody. As the crowd cheers on the chaos, Pickwick indignantly protests his arrest. Upon arrival at the magistrate’s house, Pickwick prepares to defend his actions and prove his innocence, though the situation has already escalated beyond his control.
Sam’s loyalty to Pickwick is on full display here—he doesn’t hesitate to jump in and defend his master, even though it just makes matters worse. The crowd’s excitement over the chaos gives the sense that the people care more about entertainment than justice. Pickwick’s protest at the end is futile: no matter how reasonable he is, the situation has already spiraled way beyond what logic can fix.
Themes
