Once

by

Morris Gleitzman

Carrots Symbol Icon

In Once, carrots represent the hope that Felix tries to inspire in others under horrific circumstances. At the novel’s beginning, Felix finds a whole carrot in his soup at the remote Catholic orphanage where his parents left him after Nazis invaded Poland. Because carrots are his “favorite vegetable” and rare at the impoverished orphanage, Felix decides the carrot must be a message from his parents. Before Felix runs away to find them, he gives the carrot to his orphan friend Dodie, promising he’ll return with more vegetables after his family reunites. Thus, Felix uses the carrot to inspire hope in Dodie that Dodie won’t permanently lose one of the only affectionate relationships in his life, his friendship with Felix. While searching for his parents, Felix meets an orphaned girl, Zelda, and Barney, a Jewish dentist hiding Jewish children from the Nazis. When Zelda contracts a dangerous fever, Barney sends Felix into the Nazi-patrolled ghetto to find aspirin. Felix decides to find a carrot too, believing it will “help Zelda just as much as aspirin.” Felix’s belief suggests that hope (which carrots symbolize in the novel) is as important to survival as medicine. Before Felix can give Zelda the carrot, Nazis capture them, Barney, and the other children and put them on a train to a concentration camp. When Felix finds a rotted-out section of the train wall, he tries to convince the other children to jump to freedom with him—and uses the carrot he found for Zelda as an illustration of the good future they might have if they escape. Though most of the children refuse to jump, Zelda and Chaya agree—and Felix and Zelda survive, though Chaya is killed. Thus, the carrot represents how hope—justified or unjustified—inspires characters to fight for better futures.

Carrots Quotes in Once

The Once quotes below all refer to the symbol of Carrots. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Storytelling Theme Icon
).
Pages 1–8 Quotes

Once I was living in an orphanage in the mountains and I shouldn’t have been and I almost caused a riot.

It was because of the carrot.

Related Characters: Felix Salinger (speaker)
Related Symbols: Carrots
Page Number: 1
Explanation and Analysis:

At last. Thank you, God, Jesus, Mary, the Pope, and Adolf Hitler. I’ve waited so long for this.

It’s a sign.

This carrot is a sign from Mum and Dad. They’ve sent my favorite vegetable to let me know their problems are finally over. To let me know that after three long years and eight long months things are finally improving for Jewish booksellers. To let me know they’re coming to take me home.

Related Characters: Felix Salinger (speaker)
Related Symbols: Carrots
Page Number: 3
Explanation and Analysis:
Pages 132–143 Quotes

If Zelda’s dad’s a Nazi, does she deserve carrot soup and aspirin?

Yes.

She can’t help what her father did. Plus he’s dead now and so’s her mum and I don’t know if she’s got any other living relatives but after what we’ve been through together that makes me one and I say yes.

Related Characters: Felix Salinger (speaker), Zelda, Barney, Dodie
Related Symbols: Carrots
Page Number: 142
Explanation and Analysis:
Get the entire Once LitChart as a printable PDF.
Once PDF

Carrots Symbol Timeline in Once

The timeline below shows where the symbol Carrots appears in Once. The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance.
Pages 1–8
Innocence and Ignorance Theme Icon
Antisemitism vs. Human Dignity Theme Icon
The narrator sits down, wipes his glasses, and sees an entire carrot in his soup. He's astonished; he hasn’t seen a carrot since he came to the... (full context)
Storytelling Theme Icon
Innocence and Ignorance Theme Icon
Antisemitism vs. Human Dignity Theme Icon
Family Theme Icon
The narrator concludes that the carrot, his “favorite vegetable,” must be a message from his parents. They’re telling him that they’ll... (full context)
Innocence and Ignorance Theme Icon
Antisemitism vs. Human Dignity Theme Icon
Morality, Violence, and Complicity   Theme Icon
...his parents are in the village and that they convinced Father Ludwik to deliver the carrot to him. He feels indebted to Mother Minka for “mak[ing] a joke to draw attention... (full context)
Pages 18–28
Innocence and Ignorance Theme Icon
...asks whether his parents specified when they’d arrive at the orphanage when they delivered the carrot. Sadly, Mother Minka explains that Sister Elwira put the carrot in Felix’s soup because she... (full context)
Innocence and Ignorance Theme Icon
Antisemitism vs. Human Dignity Theme Icon
Family Theme Icon
...is like Catholic only different.” When Dodie says he’ll miss Felix, Felix gives Dodie his carrot and promises he’ll bring more carrots and turnips when he visits. (full context)
Pages 91–98
Storytelling Theme Icon
Innocence and Ignorance Theme Icon
...again demand a story from Felix. Felix starts telling them about William finding a “magic carrot.” When Zelda and another child start fighting about how many wishes the carrot grants, Felix... (full context)
Innocence and Ignorance Theme Icon
Antisemitism vs. Human Dignity Theme Icon
...says he wants his dog and his grandmother’s dog. The toddler says he wants a carrot. The girl with the bandaged arm wishes to be “alive”; when the other children laugh,... (full context)
Pages 99–111
Storytelling Theme Icon
...responsibility.” He launches into a story about a boy named William who found a magic carrot that granted him three wishes. (full context)
Pages 132–143
Storytelling Theme Icon
...In the last apartment, he prays to “God, Jesus, Mary, and the Pope”—and finds a carrot, which he believes “will help Zelda just as much as the aspirin.” (full context)
Storytelling Theme Icon
Antisemitism vs. Human Dignity Theme Icon
Family Theme Icon
...Virgin Mary, and Richmal Crompton that he’ll be able to get Zelda her aspirin and carrot soon. Addressing God and the other figures to whom he prays, he tells them that... (full context)
Pages 153–161
Storytelling Theme Icon
...jump from a train, are adopted by a farmer, and, in the future, “invent a carrot that cures all illnesses.” He shows them the carrot he found for Zelda as an... (full context)