The Silver Chair

by

C. S. Lewis

The Silver Chair: Chapter 9 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Jill spends the rest of the morning walking around Harfang and letting the giants know how excited she is for the feast. She asks them as many questions she can think of regarding the feast, and they eagerly answer her. However, she notices that some of the giants feel bad for her, though she is not sure why. She also learns that there is a scullery door that often gets left open, which might allow her to escape. When speaking with the giants, Scrubb and Puddleglum try to express their excitement as well, though they are not nearly as good as Jill.
Although Jill, Scrubb, and Puddleglum have been deceived up until this point in the novel, now it is their turn to be deceptive. Jill tries to make up for her past failings by taking the lead in attempting to get information out of the giants. Although the giants do not tell her anything explicit about the feast, the sadness she sees in some of the giants lets her know that she is right in wanting to escape.
Themes
Deception and Illusion Theme Icon
Freedom and Imprisonment Theme Icon
Quotes
At lunch, Jill, Scrubb, and Puddleglum eat venison at a table next to a larger table of giants. Puddleglum overhears the giants say that the venison came from a talking stag. Puddleglum then tells the children to stop eating it—in Narnia, eating talking animals is a terrible thing to do, and it leaves Puddleglum deeply saddened. Jill and Scrubb are also bothered. Scrubb is especially upset, since he made friends with some talking animals last time he was in Narnia.
Puddleglum’s reaction to eating a talking animal suggests that the act would be akin to eating a human in Jill and Scrubb’s world. Talking suggests intelligent life, and the destruction of intelligent life is considered wrong in Narnia. However, the giants do not follow the moral code of Aslan and Narnia, and they do not notice that the meal disgusts Puddleglum and the children.
Themes
Deception and Illusion Theme Icon
Quotes
After lunch, Jill, Scrubb, and Puddleglum wait for the giants to begin clearing out, so they can make their escape. However, when they enter the scullery, one giant still remains. Before long, the adventurers realize she does not plan to leave, though she does mention being tired. Jill, Scrubb, and Puddleglum move toward the opposite end of the scullery and wait for the giant to fall asleep.
Just as they did while traveling through Ettinsmoor, Jill, Scrubb, and Puddleglum have to act as though nothing is wrong, even though they are all afraid for their lives. Luckily, the giants at Harfang are not much brighter than the giants they met along the way and do not think to keep a close eye on them.
Themes
Deception and Illusion Theme Icon
Freedom and Imprisonment Theme Icon
While they wait, Jill examines a giant cookbook on a table in the scullery. Almost immediately, she comes across an entry that reads, “MAN. This elegant little biped has long been valued as a delicacy. It forms a traditional part of the Autumn Feast.” Just below the recipe for humans is another one for Marsh-wiggles. After some time, the giant at the other end of the scullery finally falls asleep. When Jill, Scrubb, and Puddleglum hear snoring, they begin tip-toeing their way outside.
Finally, Jill, Scrubb, and Puddleglum discover why the giants are so interested in them—they want to eat them. Additionally, the recipe reveals the double-meaning of the beautiful woman’s message. Her words were ambiguous to make the children think they would be attending the Autumn Feast, when in reality, she wanted them to become part of the giants’ meal.
Themes
Deception and Illusion Theme Icon
Freedom and Imprisonment Theme Icon
Get the entire The Silver Chair LitChart as a printable PDF.
The Silver Chair PDF
Slowly, the group makes their way out of the castle and down the steep path they climbed the night before. When they look up at the castle, they realize there are dozens of windows the giants could see them from. To make matters worse, Jill and Scrubb are wearing brightly-colored outfits that the giants gave them. Puddleglum warns them not to run until he gives the word. Otherwise, the giants will be on them right away.
Jill, Scrubb, and Puddleglum must resist their natural instinct to run because the giants physically outmatch them. The only way for them to successfully escape Harfang is through mental fortitude. Presumably, the bright outfits Jill and Scrubb wear are an unfortunate coincidence rather than a conscience ploy by the giants, considering that the giants are quite unintelligent.
Themes
Deception and Illusion Theme Icon
Freedom and Imprisonment Theme Icon
Courage Theme Icon
The party covers a considerable distance but are still a ways off from the ruined city when they hear the sound of a hunting horn. When they look in the direction of the horn, they see the King of the giants’ hunting party. The King urges the giants to chase after the children and Puddleglum. At the sight of the King, Puddleglum urges the children to run.
The return of the King and Queen means that the adventurers have no choice but to outrun the giants. The giants realize their facade is ruined and that their prime dish for the feast is escaping.
Themes
Courage Theme Icon
Puddleglum, Jill, and Scrubb run away as fast as they can. Unfortunately, it is particularly difficult for Jill to run because she is wearing a dress, and she soon falls behind. Nevertheless, she runs as fast as she can toward the ruined city, though she has no idea what she plans to do if she reaches it.
“UNDER ME” is too vague of an instruction for Puddleglum, Jill, and Scrubb to know where they are going. Jill knows from previous experience that the letters carved into the ground are dead ends, which would allow the giants to capture her.
Themes
Freedom and Imprisonment Theme Icon
Courage Theme Icon
Puddleglum reaches the bottom of the path first and finds a small opening that he dives into, Scrubb following closely behind him. Jill arrives a moment later and crawls into the opening as well. As soon as she is inside, everyone works together to pile rocks over the opening so that the giants and their dogs cannot reach them. Once the hole is sealed, all three of them join hands and feel their way around the darkness. The group quickly realizes that the cave they have found themselves in is rather large, and they worry they will get lost.
Puddleglum is the most physically suited to the terrain, and his physicality and quick thinking allows the party to escape. However, although the giants are no longer a threat, at least for the moment, the party now finds themselves in literal and metaphorical darkness. The darkness ensures that they have no idea where to go, so they must rely on one another to find a way forward.
Themes
Freedom and Imprisonment Theme Icon
Courage Theme Icon
While walking through the cave, Puddleglum—who is in front of the children—slips and falls down a steep slope. Because everyone is holding hands, the children tumble down behind him. The slope is extremely long, and when they finally reach the bottom, Puddleglum suggests they must be a mile underground. Before they can decide what to do next, a voice calls out in the darkness and says, “What make you here, creatures of the Overworld.”
Holding hands demonstrates the group’s desire to stick together for better or for worse. The voice in the darkness suggests that they have managed to find the underground world they were looking for, though—once again—they are at the mercy of someone they do not know; someone who could be dangerous.
Themes
Courage Theme Icon