Three years older than Holden, Luce was Holden’s student mentor at the Whooton School. During this time, he often regaled Holden and other students with stories about sex. Holden still remembers the way Luce used to be able to identify whether or not a person was gay, a skill Holden found quite impressive even if he secretly thought that Luce himself might be gay. During one of his lonelier moments in New York, Holden decides to call Luce even though he doesn’t necessarily even like him. In fact, the last time he saw him, he called him a “phony” to his face, which is perhaps why Luce is cold and removed when he eventually agrees to meet Holden at a bar late that night—an encounter that ends with Luce calling Holden immature and suggesting that he see a psychoanalyst.